3.3 Surface and guided waves
L1 Phenomenon
A sound wave can also cling to a surface, like a ripple on water, with its energy within about one wavelength of the top. On LN such a surface acoustic wave (SAW) travels at about 3.4 to 4.0 km/s, 75,000 to 88,000 times slower than light, so a 1 GHz signal becomes a ripple only 4 µm long that a pair of comb-shaped electrodes can launch and catch. Some crystal cuts carry a faster surface wave that leaks a little energy into the bulk as it travels; on the right cut that leak is tiny.
On 128° Y-X the surface atoms trace ellipses and the motion dies within about a wavelength; switch to 64° Y-X and the motion turns mostly horizontal shear, with a partial wave that carries energy down into the crystal.
u₁ along x₁
u₂ shear-horizontal
u₃ normal
φ potential
surface orbit (u₁ →, u₃ ↑)
·······
··· ···
·· ··
· ·
· + ·
· ·
·· ··
··· ···
···●··· - v
- 3978.4 m/s
- λ
- 3.978 µm at 1 GHz
- orbit
- retrograde
- E(<1 λ)
- 99.7 %
128° Y-X, Rayleigh, free surface
- wavelength at 1 GHz
- 3.978 µm
- surface orbit
- retrograde
- energy within 1 λ (of ∫|u|²dx₃ to 3 λ)
- 99.7 %
L2 Partial waves, coupling, standard cuts
Rayleigh wave: traction-free surface wave on an elastic half-space, displacement in the sagittal plane, decaying with depth (Rayleigh 1885 S). On a piezoelectric substrate the partial waves also carry an electric potential that extends into the vacuum; the wave is slower when the surface is shorted by a thin metal film.
Partial-wave method (Campbell & Jones 1968 S): fields ∝ exp[ik(x1 + αx3 − vt)]; for each trial v the extended 4×4 Christoffel system in (u1, u2, u3, φ) gives an 8th-order polynomial in α; keep the 4 roots that decay into the substrate (or radiate away from the surface, for leaky waves); the SAW velocity is the root of the 4×4 boundary determinant (three traction components plus D3 continuity with the vacuum, or φ = 0 for a shorted surface) derived.
Coupling as defined by Ingebrigtsen (Ingebrigtsen 1969 S). Leaky SAW (pseudo-SAW): a predominantly shear-horizontal surface wave faster than the slow shear bulk wave; it radiates into the bulk and its velocity is complex (Yamanouchi & Shibayama 1972 treat leaky surface waves in LN S).
Standard cuts, Kushibiki et al. 1999 constants
| Cut (IEEE notation) | Wave | vfree (m/s) | vmet (m/s) | k² = 2Δv/v | loss free / met (dB/λ) | Vendor v (m/s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Y-Z | Rayleigh | 3486.4 | 3412.7 | 4.23% | – / – | 3488 |
| (YXl) 128°, 128° Y-X | Rayleigh | 3978.4 | 3870.7 | 5.41% | – / – | 3980 |
| X-Z | Rayleigh | 3482.3 | 3405.9 | 4.39% | – / – | – |
| X-Y | Rayleigh | 3696.4 | 3640.0 | 3.05% | – / – | – |
| Z-X | Rayleigh | 3785.6 | 3777.4 | 0.43% | – / – | – |
| (YXl) 64° | leaky SAW | 4691.4 | 4448.2 | 10.37% | 0.0506 / 0.0033 | 4690 |
| (YXl) 41° | leaky SAW | 4749.3 | 4376.2 | 15.71% | 2.0×10⁻⁴ / 0.0160 | 4750 |
| (YXl) 36° | leaky SAW | 4749.4 | 4347.6 | 16.92% | 7.6×10⁻⁵ / 0.0331 | – |
Computed with the partial-wave solver from the Kushibiki et al. 1999 constants P derived. Vendor column: Fomos-Materials knowledge base V; its coupling percentages (5.04, 5.7, 10, 17%) refer to an undefined quantity and are not compared. Losses of the leaky waves from the imaginary part of the complex root (first order).
The 36 to 41° free-surface leaky roots sit 0.7 to 0.8 m/s below the fast-shear bulk velocity along X (4750.1 m/s); they are isolated complex roots with very small radiation loss (41°: about 2×10−4 dB per wavelength free, 0.016 shorted), so the leaky wave on these cuts is almost a true surface wave until the surface is metallized.
Guided waves in thin films
Love-type and index-guided waves. A film whose shear velocity is lower than the substrate's guides acoustic waves without suspension; LN on sapphire uses this “phononic analogue of index guiding” (Mayor et al. 2021, abstract reported).
Plate modes in suspended films (Lamb and shear-horizontal): SH0, S0, A0 and thickness-shear overtones such as A1. A 400 nm ZY-LN platelet excited by lateral fields (XBAR) resonates near 4.8 GHz with coupling about 25% and Q about 300 (Plessky et al. 2019 reported). The bulk shear velocity along Z, 3590 m/s, over twice the thickness gives 3590/(2 × 400 nm) = 4.5 GHz (derived; ignores stiffening and electrode loading). Thin-film numbers are reported values plus this estimate; no plate-mode dispersion is computed.
Wavelength-scale mechanical waveguides (1 µm wide) on suspended TFLN and on LN on sapphire: 3.7.
L3 Constant-set sensitivity, root selection, definitions
| Cut: vfree (m/s), k² | Kushibiki et al. 1999 | Ogi et al. 2002 (ε^S Kushibiki) | Warner et al. 1967 (ρ 4700 assumed) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Y-Z | 3486.4, 4.23% | 3485.2, 4.41% | 3489.8, 4.91% |
| 128° Y-X | 3978.4, 5.41% | 3974.2, 5.41% | 3991.9, 5.27% |
| 41° Y-X leaky | 4749.3, 15.71% | 4721.3, 15.57% | 4784.7, 16.99% |
| 64° Y-X leaky | 4691.4, 10.37% | 4666.8, 10.31% | 4736.6, 11.03% |
Kushibiki et al. 1999 P; Ogi et al. 2002 c, e, ρ 4636 P with the Kushibiki et al. εS (blended sensitivity case; Ogi et al. report no εS); Warner et al. 1967 c (Weis & Gaylord 1985 Table 6 P-comp), e (Ogi et al. 2002 Table III S), εS 44.3/27.9 (Weis & Gaylord 1985 Table 1), ρ 4700 kg/m³ assumed (the value Weis & Gaylord use in their AO figures). All computed derived.
The older Warner set gives about 17% and 11% for 41 and 64°; the Kushibiki et al. 1999 and Ogi et al. 2002 sets give 15.6 to 15.7% and 10.3 to 10.4%. A k² quoted for a cut is meaningful only with its constant set named.
Root selection. Below the limiting velocity (1/max s1 on the sagittal-plane slowness curves, which can lie below the slowest bulk velocity along x1 for rotated cuts) all 8 roots are complex; keep Im α < 0 (substrate at x3 < 0). For leaky waves keep the real roots whose time-averaged Poynting component points into the substrate, then continue the selection to complex velocity. Nondimensionalize (c by 1011 Pa, potential by √(c0/εref)) or the problem is ill-conditioned and the Y-Z root is lost in numerical noise.
Spurious minima. The determinant has false minima at bulk thresholds (e.g. 3590.4 m/s on Y-Z, 4750.1 m/s on X-propagating cuts); a 1 m/s window around each bulk velocity along x1 is excluded; a minimum that ends at a window edge is searched again inside a 0.05 m/s window, which resolves the 36 to 41° leaky roots 0.7 to 0.8 m/s below the fast-shear velocity.
k² definitions differ. 2Δv/v (Ingebrigtsen) vs electrode-admittance or effective-permittivity definitions; vendor sheets often do not state theirs.
Temperature coefficient of frequency. Vendor values −95 (Y-Z), −72 (128° Y-X), −70 (64 and 41° Y-X) ppm/K V. A computed TCF needs temperature coefficients of c, e, ε and thermal expansion as one consistent set; Smith and Welsh 1971 has c and s coefficients (Weis & Gaylord 1985 Tables 5-6 P-comp); the thermal expansion along c is 4.1 ppm/K in the Volk & Wöhlecke 2008 compilation (Table 1.1 P-comp). No computed TCF is shown.
References
| Source | Reference | Link |
|---|---|---|
| Rayleigh 1885 | Rayleigh, Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society s1-17 4-11 (1885). On Waves Propagated along the Plane Surface of an Elastic Solid | doi:10.1112/plms/s1-17.1.4 |
| Campbell & Jones 1968 | Campbell & Jones, IEEE Transactions on Sonics and Ultrasonics 15 209-217 (1968). A method for estimating optimal crystal cuts and propagation directions for excitation of piezoelectric surface waves | doi:10.1109/T-SU.1968.29477 |
| Ingebrigtsen 1969 | Ingebrigtsen, Journal of Applied Physics 40 2681-2686 (1969). Surface Waves in Piezoelectrics | doi:10.1063/1.1658060 |
| Yamanouchi & Shibayama 1972 | Yamanouchi & Shibayama, Journal of Applied Physics 43 856-862 (1972). Propagation and Amplification of Rayleigh Waves and Piezoelectric Leaky Surface Waves in LiNbO3 | doi:10.1063/1.1661294 |
| Kushibiki et al. 1999 | Kushibiki et al., IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control 46 1315-1323 (1999). Accurate measurements of the acoustical physical constants of LiNbO3 and LiTaO3 single crystals | doi:10.1109/58.796136 |
| Ogi et al. 2002 | Ogi et al., Journal of Applied Physics 92 2451-2456 (2002). Acoustic spectroscopy of lithium niobate: Elastic and piezoelectric coefficients | doi:10.1063/1.1497702 |
| Warner et al. 1967 | Warner, Onoe & Coquin, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 42 1223-1231 (1967). Determination of Elastic and Piezoelectric Constants for Crystals in Class (3m) | doi:10.1121/1.1910709 |
| Weis & Gaylord 1985 | Weis & Gaylord, Applied Physics A Solids and Surfaces 37 191-203 (1985). Lithium niobate: Summary of physical properties and crystal structure | doi:10.1007/BF00614817 |
| Fomos-Materials | Fomos-Materials. Lithium niobate (knowledge base) | en.newpiezo.com/knowledge_base/1/lithium-niobate/ |
| Mayor et al. 2021 | Mayor et al., Physical Review Applied 15 014039 (2021). Gigahertz Phononic Integrated Circuits on Thin-Film Lithium Niobate on Sapphire | doi:10.1103/PhysRevApplied.15.014039 |
| Plessky et al. 2019 | Plessky et al., Electronics Letters 55 98-100 (2019). 5 GHz laterally-excited bulk-wave resonators (XBARs) based on thin platelets of lithium niobate | doi:10.1049/el.2018.7297 |
| Smith & Welsh 1971 | Smith & Welsh, Journal of Applied Physics 42 2219-2230 (1971). Temperature Dependence of the Elastic, Piezoelectric, and Dielectric Constants of Lithium Tantalate and Lithium Niobate | doi:10.1063/1.1660528 |
| Volk & Wohlecke 2009 | Volk & Wohlecke, Springer Series in Materials Science (2009). Lithium Niobate: Defects, Photorefraction and Ferroelectric Switching | doi:10.1007/978-3-540-70766-0 |