2.7 Waveguides in TFLN
L1 Phenomenon
Thin-film LN on insulator (LNOI, TFLN) is a crystalline film, 300 to 900 nm thick in one supplier's range V, bonded on a silica layer. Partial etching leaves a rib on a thinner slab: Li et al. 2026 use a 300 nm film, 120 nm slab and 3.5 µm rib reported. The mode fills a cross-section of order λ2, the index contrast to the silica cladding allows tight bends, and electrodes sit micrometres from the guide (6 µm gap in Li et al. 2026 reported).
Propagation loss: 0.27 dB/cm on 4- and 6-inch wafers patterned by deep-UV lithography reported; 1.3 dB/m in dry-etched rings (intrinsic Q 29 million) reported; Q above 1e8 in chemo-mechanically polished rings reported. The material limit of annealed ion-sliced film is estimated at 0.2 dB/m (Q 1.6e8) reported.
| film t / etch e / slab | 300 / 180 / 120 nm | reported |
| top width w | 3.5 µm | reported |
| sidewall, reference not stated | 60° | reported |
| cladding, PECVD SiO2 | 2 µm | reported |
| electrode gap, Au | 6 µm | reported |
| neff, TE, 1550 nm | 1.7696 | engine |
| ng, TE, 1550 nm | 2.135 | engine |
| neff | –.–––– | ng | –.––– |
| Aeff | –.–– µm² | LN fraction | –.–– |
| TE fraction | –.–– | status |
| Held-out error, median / p95 | clean / flagged | neff clean | neff flagged | neff all | ng clean | ng flagged | ng all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TE0 | 93 / 32 | 9.9e−4 / 4.1e−3 | 4.5e−4 / 2.3e−3 | 8.4e−4 / 4.1e−3 | 3.8e−4 / 5.7e−3 | 6.1e−4 / 1.2e−2 | 4.5e−4 / 7.4e−3 |
| TM0 | 79 / 35 | 9.3e−4 / 6.4e−3 | 1.3e−3 / 7.0e−3 | 1.1e−3 / 6.7e−3 | 4.0e−4 / 1.4e−2 | 4.0e−3 / 1.6e−2 | 8.6e−4 / 1.4e−2 |
| TE1 | 47 / 66 | 1.1e−3 / 4.3e−3 | 1.4e−3 / 4.1e−3 | 1.1e−3 / 4.2e−3 | 9.0e−4 / 1.4e−2 | 2.4e−3 / 2.4e−2 | 1.5e−3 / 1.6e−2 |
- Film / etch / slab
- 300 / 180 / 120 nm
- reported
- Top width
- 3.5 µm
- reported
- Sidewall
- 60°
- reported
- PECVD SiO2 cladding
- 2 µm
- reported
- Au electrode gap
- 6 µm
- reported
- neff, TE, 1550 nm
- 1.7696
- engine
- ng, TE, 1550 nm
- 2.135
- engine
To scale. x-cut film, light along y, c across the gap: TE light and the electrode field both lie along c. Sidewall reference direction not stated in the paper; drawn 60° from the substrate plane as in the engine model, Au 1.0 µm thick on the slab, buried oxide (4.7 µm) broken. engine
- neff
- –.––––
- ng
- –.–––
- Aeff
- –.–– µm²
- LN fraction
- –.––
- TE fraction
- –.––
- Status
- Li et al. 2026 rib, w 3.5 µm, TE0
- 1.7696 / 2.135
- engine
Ellipse: |Ex| and |Ey| shares of the readout mode (TE fraction), not a polarization state; light at 1064 and 1550 nm in false color, dashed. Grey band on a curve: flagged lattice points; dotted lines: slab of thickness t derived; diamond: Li et al. 2026 engine value, outside the width axis.
| Held-out error, median / p95 | clean / flagged | neff clean | neff flagged | neff all | ng clean | ng flagged | ng all |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TE0 | 93 / 32 | 9.9e−4 / 4.1e−3 | 4.5e−4 / 2.3e−3 | 8.4e−4 / 4.1e−3 | 3.8e−4 / 5.7e−3 | 6.1e−4 / 1.2e−2 | 4.5e−4 / 7.4e−3 |
| TM0 | 79 / 35 | 9.3e−4 / 6.4e−3 | 1.3e−3 / 7.0e−3 | 1.1e−3 / 6.7e−3 | 4.0e−4 / 1.4e−2 | 4.0e−3 / 1.6e−2 | 8.6e−4 / 1.4e−2 |
| TE1 | 47 / 66 | 1.1e−3 / 4.3e−3 | 1.4e−3 / 4.1e−3 | 1.1e−3 / 4.2e−3 | 9.0e−4 / 1.4e−2 | 2.4e−3 / 2.4e−2 | 1.5e−3 / 1.6e−2 |
Full-vector FEM (Nedelec/Lagrange order 2), eo-modulator-atlas engine, commit eb97f96, GPL-3.0-or-later: 6300 solves on the grid t 300 to 900 nm, etch fraction 0.2 to 1.0, w 0.6 to 3.0 µm (geometric), sidewall 60/70/80°, λ 0.775/1.064/1.55 µm, x- and z-cut; multilinear interpolation, λ on the grid only. Stack: LN film on SiO₂ with SiO₂ cladding over the rib; no Si substrate (substrate leakage not modelled), no electrodes. LN: Zelmon 1997 congruent, 21 °C; SiO₂: Malitson 1965. Held-out set: 126 random geometries solved directly. engine
L2 Quantitative model
Geometry. Film thickness t, etch depth e (slab t − e), top width w, sidewall angle; cladding air or oxide. Li et al. 2026: t = 300 nm, e = 180 nm, slab 120 nm, w = 3.5 µm, sidewall 60° (reference direction not stated), 2 µm PECVD SiO2 cladding reported; engine neff = 1.7696, ng = 2.135 at 1550 nm engine.
x-cut vs z-cut
| x-cut, propagation along y | z-cut | |
|---|---|---|
| TE index | ne 2.1376 at 1550 nm derived | no 2.2111 derived, same in every in-plane direction |
| TM index | no | ne |
| EO, in-plane electrodes | TE uses r33 | TE uses r22; TM with vertical field uses r33 |
| χ(2) | TE type 0 uses d33 | TM uses d33 |
| rings | TE index varies around the ring | TE isotropic in plane |
| poling | coplanar in-plane electrodes, field nonuniform with depth | vertical field through the stack |
Indices: Zelmon Sellmeier, congruent LN, 21 °C. Coefficient mapping: 2.2 (r tensor) and 2.3 (d tensor).
Anisotropy around a ring (x-cut, bulk approximation). For TE propagating at angle φ from crystal z within the film plane, the in-plane polarization sees
varying between ne (propagation along y) and no (propagation along z): 2.1376 to 2.2111 at 1550 nm derived, mode confinement ignored. The local phase velocity, the QPM condition and the r33 projection all vary twice per round trip.
| n(φ) | 2.1920 | Δn in plane | 0.0736 |
| no | 2.2111 | ne | 2.1376 |
- n(φ) at the probe
- 2.1920
- no
- 2.2111
- ne
- 2.1376
- In-plane span
- 0.0736
Band brightness = TE index. Two bright and two dark arcs per round trip turn with the crystal; the probe stays at the top, where φ is the angle between the light and c (x-cut) or x (z-cut). Bulk approximation, mode confinement ignored; ring not to scale. Indices: Zelmon Sellmeier, congruent LN, 21 °C, 0.40 to 5.00 µm; film indices may differ. derived
Mode hybridization. Where a TE and a TM mode of the same waveguide would cross in neff, any broken symmetry (slanted sidewalls, a slab on one side, an off-axis crystal orientation) couples them into hybrid modes with an anticrossing (hybridization). In TFLN ridges this affects even the fundamental modes (Pan et al. 2019). In x-cut strip waveguides the hybrid regions depend on dimensions, sidewall angle and wavelength, and tapers through them convert TM0 to higher-order TE (99.5%, numerical) reported. In x-cut microrings the rotating birefringence converts TE to TM and creates avoided mode crossings that suppress one four-wave-mixing sideband reported. Arrayed-waveguide gratings need anisotropy-aware layouts (Wang 2024).
Loss and Q.
At 1550 nm with ng = 2.3 template: Qi = 1e7 → 4.05 dB/m; 2.9e7 → 1.40 dB/m; 1.6e8 → 0.25 dB/m derived. Published conversions use each device's own ng (e.g. 1.3 dB/m for Qi 29 million reported).
| αdB | 1.40 dB/m | α | 0.321 /m |
| Qi | 2.90e+07 | to floor | 5.52× |
- Loss
- 1.40 dB/m
- α
- 0.321 /m
- Qi
- 2.90e+07
- Floor Q / Qi
- 5.52×
Best dry-etched ring to the floor: 5.5× in Q, 6.5× in loss. derived
Rim brightness = Q. Rings sorted by loss; dashed rims: Q only, placed with ng 2.3 at 1550 nm template. Band: material floor reported derived; dashed line: bulk absorption derived. Type 1.6e8 to land on the band.
Loss and Q records
| Platform | Loss or Q | Plotted, dB/m | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dry-etched TFLN ring | Q about 1e7; 2.7 dB/m | 2.7 | 2017-12-18 | Zhang et al. 2017 reported |
| visible (637 nm) | 6 dB/m; Qi 11e6 | 6 | 2019-03-15 | Desiatov et al. 2019 reported |
| wafer-scale DUV lithography | 0.27 dB/cm | 27derived | 2020-08-03 | Luke et al. 2020 reported |
| microdisk | Q > 1e8 | < 0.405template | 2021-12-01 | Gao et al. 2021 reported |
| CMP microring | Q > 1e8 | < 0.405template | 2022 | Gao et al. 2022 reported |
| dry-etched ring, highest found | Qi 29e6; 1.3 dB/m | 1.3 | 2024-07-26 | Zhu et al. 2024 reported |
| material limit, annealed ion-sliced film | Q 1.6e8; 0.2 dB/m | 0.2 reported | 2022-08-01 | Shams-Ansari et al. 2022 reported |
| bulk CLN absorption, 390 to 3800 nm | < 1e−4 to 2 /cm | 0.043 derived | 2015 | Leidinger et al. 2015 reported |
1e−4 /cm = 0.043 dB/m. Q-only rows are plotted as upper bounds on loss at ng = 2.3, 1550 nm.
L3 Mechanisms, computation, measurement
Loss mechanisms
- Sidewall and top-surface roughness scattering, set by lithography and Ar+ milling (redeposition: chapter 05).
- Material absorption: transition-metal impurities give up to 0.04 /cm in as-grown crystals, H-related bands about 0.001 /cm at 2300 to 2800 nm; annealing lowers absorption up to 10× P. Ion-slicing damage: post-fabrication annealing raises the material-limited Q (Shams-Ansari et al. 2022).
- Cladding absorption in the mid-IR: silica absorbs beyond 2.5 µm, which motivates LN on sapphire reported.
- Bend radiation and substrate leakage (slab modes, thin buried oxide).
- Metal absorption where electrodes approach the mode; Li et al. 2026 attribute their 2.8 dB on-chip loss to splitters, propagation and electrode absorption reported.
- Photorefractive and charge effects at high power (chapter 04); removing the dielectric cladding mitigates photorefraction in rings reported.
Computing modes
Full-vector finite-element method (FEM) with the anisotropic permittivity rotated into the lab frame (x lateral, y vertical, z propagation; x-cut with propagation along crystal y puts crystal z along lab x) (eo-modulator-atlas engine). A scalar or effective-index solver is wrong for high-contrast anisotropic ribs. The neff 1.7696 and ng 2.135 engine of the Li et al. 2026 rib come from this solver.
Measuring loss
Ring transmission fits give loaded Q and, with the coupling regime identified (under- vs overcoupled), intrinsic Q; conversion to dB/m needs ng from the measured FSR:
Cut-back measurements separate propagation from facet loss but need many lengths for sub-dB/cm accuracy.
Errors
Bulk Zelmon indices at 21 °C stand in for film indices; ion-sliced and annealed films may differ (composition, residual strain, Li out-diffusion: chapters 01, 05). Film-thickness nonuniformity across a wafer moves neff and therefore the QPM wavelength (2.3) and ring resonances. Real x-cut ring modes need an azimuthal treatment of the confined mode; the ring index above is the bulk indicatrix projection.
References
| Desiatov et al. 2019 | Ultra-low-loss integrated visible photonics using thin-film lithium niobate. Optica 6 380 (2019). | doi:10.1364/OPTICA.6.000380 |
| Gao et al. 2021 | Broadband highly efficient nonlinear optical processes in on-chip integrated lithium niobate microdisk resonators of Q-factor above 10^8. New Journal of Physics 23 123027 (2021). | doi:10.1088/1367-2630/ac3d52 |
| Gao et al. 2022 | Lithium niobate microring with ultra-high Q factor above 10^8. Chinese Optics Letters 20 011902 (2022). | doi:10.3788/col202220.011902 |
| J. R. M.-L. Schwesyg 2011 | Interaction of light with impurities in lithium niobate crystals. Dr. rer. nat. dissertation, Universitat Bonn (2011). | no DOI |
| Jiang 2026 | eo-modulator-atlas: FEM engine (electrostatics, full-vector optical modes, Pockels overlap). (2026). | https://github.com/jwt625/eo-modulator-atlas |
| Jinan Jingzheng Electronics (NanoLN) | Products. | https://www.nanoln.com/PRODUCTS.html |
| Kaushalram et al. 2020 | Mode hybridization analysis in thin film lithium niobate strip multimode waveguides. Scientific Reports 10 16692 (2020). | doi:10.1038/s41598-020-73936-x |
| Leidinger et al. 2015 | Optics Express 23 21690 (2015). | doi:10.1364/OE.23.021690 |
| Li et al. 2026 | Ultra-broadband near- to mid-infrared electro-optic modulator on thin-film lithium niobate. Nature Communications 17 1138 (2026). | doi:10.1038/s41467-025-67902-2 |
| Luke et al. 2020 | Wafer-scale low-loss lithium niobate photonic integrated circuits. Optics Express 28 24452 (2020). | doi:10.1364/oe.401959 |
| Mishra et al. 2021 | Mid-infrared nonlinear optics in thin-film lithium niobate on sapphire. Optica 8 921 (2021). | doi:10.1364/OPTICA.427428 |
| Pan et al. 2019 | Fundamental mode hybridization in a thin film lithium niobate ridge waveguide. Optics Express 27 35659 (2019). | doi:10.1364/oe.27.035659 |
| Shams-Ansari et al. 2022 | Reduced material loss in thin-film lithium niobate waveguides. APL Photonics 7 081301 (2022). | doi:10.1063/5.0095146 |
| Tan et al. 2024 | Intrinsic polarization conversion and avoided-mode crossing in X-cut lithium niobate microrings. Chinese Physics B 33 064205 (2024). | doi:10.1088/1674-1056/ad47b2 |
| Wang 2024 | Breaking anisotropy limitations in thin-film lithium niobate arrayed waveguide gratings. Light: Science & Applications 13 209 (2024). | doi:10.1038/s41377-024-01551-w |
| Xu et al. 2021 | Mitigating photorefractive effect in thin-film lithium niobate microring resonators. Optics Express 29 5497 (2021). | doi:10.1364/OE.418877 |
| Zelmon et al. 1997 | Infrared corrected Sellmeier coefficients for congruently grown lithium niobate and 5 mol% magnesium oxide –doped lithium niobate. Journal of the Optical Society of America B 14 3319 (1997). | doi:10.1364/JOSAB.14.003319 |
| Zhang et al. 2017 | Monolithic ultra-high-Q lithium niobate microring resonator. Optica 4 1536 (2017). | doi:10.1364/OPTICA.4.001536 |
| Zhu et al. 2024 | Twenty-nine million intrinsic Q-factor monolithic microresonators on thin-film lithium niobate. Photonics Research 12 A63 (2024). | doi:10.1364/prj.521172 |